Eticketing: What Silicon Valley is Bad At

One of my first posts was called “A Letter to Silicon Valley” where I named 3 things in France that desperately need to be exported to Silicon Valley: SOS Medecins, the TGV and the Freebox.

Add electronic ticketing to the list.

I don’t care if public transporation is more popular in France than in the US – I simply cannot believe that the San Francisco public transporation system and the Caltrain still issue paper tickets. We are 2010 and the heart of high-tech still hasn’t adopted electronic ticketing? Scary.

What’s worse: the TransLink.

Yes, I am aware that there is finally an electronic ticketing system in place (mimics the current system available in France). But the BART began “testing” the technology in 2006 and TransLink only became available for the first time in the summer of 2009. Even worse,  it only works on certain train, subway and bus lines. That’s sad.

One would think that in a place like Silicon Valley, mobile ticketing would already be obsolete. But no, they’re only just beginning to move on from paper.

France, on the other hand, is discussing an upgrade of their current electronic ticketing system.

The current eletronic ticketing system in place for the Paris transportation is the NAVIGO, which is a contactless smart card (a French invention, FYI) using RFID technology – exactly what the TransLink is. It’s been around for ages. Users keep the same card and can put weekly and monthly credits on the card at electronic charging stations.

What about Weneo?

France now wants to kick-it up a notch and is experimenting with USB-key format electonic ticketing, to be known as Weneo passes.

Rather than having users add credits to their passes at electronic charging stations, users would be able to put additional credit on their passes from any computer with internet access.

All that sounds a lot better than paper to me.


4 thoughts on “Eticketing: What Silicon Valley is Bad At

  1. I hated having to use change or Credit card to get on the bart (or pay for parking)!

    Didn’t they have some sort of monthly or yearly pass? I thought I saw something available?

    I mean navigo is ok, but you still need to go to some special location to get one, and then you need to use this ridiculous system of charging it up for weekly or monthly use. In the end it’s not much more useful than the monthly pass on the NYC subway…

    Even if it has a fancy RFID tag 🙂

    All of these orgs ( velib, navigo, BART, MTA) need to spend some time removing barriers to entry. Accept paypal, let me swipe my iPhone, do something to make it easier for your customers to GIVE YOU MONEY

  2. Actually NAVIGO automatically re-charges at the end of each month if you have an annual pass (you don’t need to go to a kiosk). 🙂 LOVE THAT. Therefore, you only need to go to a station once for the initial purchase. But BART/Caltrain/Muni only have monthly passes (no annual) so you need to trouble yourself at the end of every month…

  3. Pingback: I Left My Heart in San Francisco. But Then I Found it In Europe. « TechBaguette

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s